Roughly 70% of American households have at least one pet. A blanket no-pet policy eliminates two-thirds of your potential applicant pool. In competitive rental markets, that means longer vacancies and lower-quality applicant pools.
The question is not whether to allow pets. It is how to allow them profitably.
The Financial Case for Allowing Pets
Pet rent: $25-$50/month per pet = $300-$600/year in additional income. Pet deposit: $250-$500 (refundable) or pet fee: $200-$400 (non-refundable). Larger applicant pool = shorter vacancy = less lost rent. Tenants with pets tend to stay longer (harder to find pet-friendly housing).
On a $2,000/month rental, allowing pets with proper fees can generate $500-$1,000+ in additional annual income while reducing vacancy.
Setting Smart Restrictions
Breed and size limits. Many insurance policies restrict certain breeds. Check your policy before setting your rules. A common approach: dogs under 50 lbs, maximum 2 pets, no exotic animals.
Pet screening. Services like PetScreening.com provide standardized pet profiles, vaccination records, and behavior assessments. This adds a layer of documentation and professionalism.
Pet addendum. Add a specific pet addendum to your lease covering: pet description (breed, weight, age), vaccination requirements, behavior expectations, damage responsibility, and additional fees/deposits.
Protecting Against Damage
Require a separate pet deposit (where legal). Conduct periodic inspections with attention to pet-related wear. Include specific pet damage clauses in your lease. Require tenants to carry renters insurance that covers pet liability.
Emotional Support Animals and Service Animals
These are NOT pets under fair housing law. You cannot charge pet fees, pet rent, or pet deposits for ESAs or service animals. You cannot deny them based on breed or size restrictions. You can request documentation from a licensed healthcare provider for ESAs. You cannot request documentation for service animals (visible disability or trained task).
Mishandling an ESA or service animal request is one of the most common fair housing violations. When in doubt, accommodate and document.
The bottom line: pets are a profit center, not a risk factor. With proper policies, documentation, and inspections, pet-friendly properties outperform pet-restricted ones.
Want this handled for you?
Northpoint gives rental owners a clear system, so you get the results without the guesswork.
Get a Free Rental Analysis